The 25 Best PS5 Horror Games, Ranked

Metacritic Score: 91 Scariest Enemies: Zombies, Cerberus, Lickers, Mr. X Why Resident Evil 2 is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Resident Evil 2 is a masterclass in survival horror, Seamlessly blending nostalgia with modern gameplay innovations, Resident Evil 2 is the first of the modern-era RE remakes to really hit home with the everyday gamer. The game's third-person perspective, stunningly updated visuals, and improved controls reinvigorate the original's terrifying experience, as exploring the Raccoon City Police Department is just as nerve-wracking as ever with its dark corridors and lurking threats keeping players constantly on edge.

Metacritic Score: 93 Scariest Enemies: Zombies, Cultists, Giant Monsters, Mutants Why Resident Evil 4 is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: The Resident Evil franchise has been one of the biggest and best horror franchises the world has ever seen, and RE4 has been regarded as one of the best the franchise has ever seen. The mixture of unrelentingly scary moments with wacky, almost cartoonish characters somehow managed to work perfectly to create the most unforgettable experience many horror fans have ever seen. As so many Resident Evil games today, a remake of RE4 came, and damn near perfected everything this cult classic had to offer. Enhances graphics, tighter controls, and new modes to play on top of the already beloved story of Leon S. Kennedy's European vacation from hell solidified the franchise as still the cream of the crop when it comes to terror

Metacritic Score: 86 Why Silent Hill 2 is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Released 23 years after the original game debuted in 2001, Silent Hill 2 remake is without question the best version of the game. It's a must-play for horror fans who never got to experience it, and with all the upgrades to the visuals, gameplay, and with nearly double the playtime, it's worth it for veterans of the series as well. Will this insanely successful remake be a sign of things to come for the Silent Hill franchise, similar to what Capcom has done with all the Resident Evil remakes? We can only hope the answer is yes.

Metacritic Score: 86 Scariest Enemies: Molded Why Resident Evil 7: Biohazard is the Best PS5 Horror Game: Completely re-inventing the franchise as spinning it an entirely new direction, Resident Evil 7: Biohazard is widely regarded as not only one of the best and scariest Resident Evil games, but one of the scariest games of all time. Fusing Texas Chain Saw with traditional RE-type storytelling, this immersive, claustrophobic, and psychologically tormenting game is not for the weak of heart, but continues to be a standout in gaming nearly decade after its initial release.

Metacritic Score: 89 Scariest Enemies: Necromorphs Why Dead Space is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: The Dead Space remake had all us 2000s kids giddy with glee as we all were finally going to be able to relive one of the scariest games of the modern era, but nothing could have prepared us for the all out terrifying assault this game had in store for us. Still showcasing the unforgettable sci fi horror story of the original, the new graphics, eerie sound design, and claustrophobic environments made this feel way too real for comfort, and when the Necromorphs showed up, things only got worse. For those who were fans of the original, this will be a nightmarishly pleasant stroll down memory lane, for first timers, prepare for the worst and most terrifying night of your life, and you'll be a-okay.

Metacritic Score: 84 Scariest Enemies: Lycans, Zombies, Vampires, Giant Monsters Why Resident Evil Village is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Continuing the new and exciting formula of RE7, Resident Evil Village throws everything and the kitchen sink at fans in an experience that, while maybe not as scary as its predecessor, is just as memorable. With Lycans, vampires, giant monsters, mutant babies, zombies, dolls, molded monsters, and mannequins to face, just to name a few of the enemies in the game, REVIII makes sure to add a dash of every phobia to the game to make sure no one who plays it gets a good nights rest.

Metacritic Score: 79 Scariest Enemies: Xenomorph Why Alien: Isolation is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Alien: Isolation stands out as a masterful homage to Ridley Scott's original Alien film, combining survival horror with an intense atmospheric experience. Players take on the role of Amanda Ripley, navigating a derelict space station while being stalked by a relentless Xenomorph. The game's focus on stealth and resource management, along with its smart enemy AI, keeps players constantly tense and on edge.

Metacritic Score: 95 Scariest Enemies: Clickers, Cannibals, Runners Why The Last of Us is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: The Last of Us sets a cornerstone in narrative-driven horror, blending heartbreaking emotional storytelling with palpable tension so thick it feels like your skin is crawling for the entire runtime. The journey of Joel and Ellie has become one that is bigger than gaming, but still manages to feel close, intimate, and personal, making the terror and dread all the more inescapable. With monster unlike anything the mainstream has ever seen, and some all too real human scares to boot, The Last of Us is more than worth revisiting, and for those who never played, is worth the hype.

Metacritic Score: 79 Scariest Enemies: Wendigo, Humans Why Until Dawn is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Until Dawn came out in 2015, and yet to this very day, it remains one of the most popular horror games on any platform. Garnering near cult status at this point, the game is one that unites horror fans thanks to its mix of incredibly cheesy dialog with horrific imagery that manages to create the perfect B-movie experience. More of a interactive more than a traditional game, Until Dawn's reputation as a standout in the horror genre is more than earned, as every choice leads to life and death scenarios, and endless amounts of replayability.

Metacritic Score: 89 Scariest Enemies: The Taken, Shadow Hounds, Cultists Why Alan Wake 2 is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Psychological torment never felt as good as it does when Alan Wake 2 has its nasty fingers wrapped around you. Blending Remedy's signature outlandish and bizarre storytelling with haunting survival mechanics, the games creates a layered narrative that seamlessly intertwines reality and the supernatural. The further into the Alan Wake 2 rabbit hole fans go down, the more reality becomes blurred until you won't even know what part is a game, and what part is real.

Metacritic Score: 79 Scariest Enemies: The Taken, Birds, Poltergeist Why Alan Wake Remastered is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Well over a decade after its initial release, Alan Wake Remastered invited players to return to the dark and eerie town of Bright Falls for another journey through the towns sick and twisted world. As many remasters do, this version ups the graphics, tightens the gameplay, and gives the game an overall shine that makes it far more welcoming than its predecessor, but where the game really shines is the newer focus on psychological terror that balances mystery and scares.

Metacritic Score: 79 Scariest Enemies: Zombies, Lickers, Nemesis Why Resident Evil 3 Remake is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: While it may not be as revolutionary as its predecessor, Resident Evil 3 Remake still delivers some of the gnarliest and creepiest scare the franchise has ever seen. Re-telling Jill Valentine's escape from Raccoon City, the game enhances its original story with stunning visuals and a more modernized gameplay, with The Nemesis, an ever-present and evolving threat, adds relentless tension, forcing players to stay constantly alert. The game's tight pacing combined with its atmospheric environments, strategic combat and nonstop scares keeps players engaged throughout, even if it is on the relatively short side.

Metacritic Score: 79 Scariest Enemies: Werewolves, Humans Why The Quarry is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Much like its predecessor, Until Dawn, The Quarry offers players the ultimate interactive horror experience that captures the essence and vibe of classic slasher films of the 80s and 90s. With an emphasis on choice-driven gameplay, where every decision you make can have dire consequences for the group of teenage camp counselors, the game is perfect part horror and party experience, as it feels more like playing a horror movie that playing a game. With numerous outcomes and choice to be made, replayability make The Quarry an endlessly entertaining horror experience.

Metacritic Score: 82 Scariest Enemies: The Teacher, The Bullies, The Thin Man

Metacritic Score: 93 Scariest Enemies: Clickers, Attack Dogs, Runners, Seraphites Why The Last of Us Part II is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Beyond all the controversies of the game, The Last of Us Part II still stands as an absolute masterclass in building tension and delivering some of the most horrifying moments mainstream gaming has ever given. With a devilishly divine blend of jump scare, psychological torment, and emotional narrative exhaustion, this journey into the post-apocalypse is just as frightening as ever.

Metacritic Score: 72 Scariest Enemies: Vampires, Soldiers Why The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: House of Ashes brings intense, cinematic horror to the gaming world, combining visceral combat with deeply engaging narrative choices. One of many entries in The Dark Pictures Anthology, House of Ashes sets players in an ancient Mesopotamian underworld, where a squad of soldiers must battle supernatural horrors. Focusing far more on storytelling and scares rather than gameplay, the game is able to create an eerily immersive environment that weaves a suspenseful, engaging story that changes based on the paths you take.

Metacritic Score: 80 Scariest Enemies: Lovecraftian Sea Creatures Why Dredge is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Indie horror games are a dime a dozen in todays day and age, so finding one that really stands out is a rather cumbersome task. Luckily, when a game like Dredge comes around, everyone and their mother is talking about it, making it a super standout in the genre. With its unique blend of fishing simulation and psychological dread, the game slowly reveals a dark, Lovecraftian horror lurking beneath its waters in a tale as twisted as the day is long.

Metacritic Score: 73 Scariest Enemies: Zombies, Survivors Why Dead Island 2 is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: After a 12-year wait, fans were finally able to return to the world of Dead Island in the much anticipated sequel that brings back the lighthearted, over the top zombie mayhem of the franchises. Combining an open-world setting with intense zombie combat, the game manages to create a thrilling and gruesome survival experience in the vibrant, sunlit environments that juxtapose the dark horror lurking around every corner. The robust melee combat system, diverse weapon customization, and variety of interactive elements keep hunting the undead just as fresh and fun as ever.

Metacritic Score: 85 Scariest Enemies: Humans Why Doki Doki Literature Club! is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Probably one of the most bizarre and obscure games on this list, on paper, Doki Doki Literature Club! may appear as a charming visual novel, but it swiftly subverts expectations and becomes an unrelenting psychological horror experience unlike anything the gaming world has seen in years. The game's deceptively cute aesthetic masks a deeply disturbing narrative that explores themes of mental illness, self-awareness, and existential dread that genuinely needs to be seen and played to be believed. Whether it is breaking the fourth wall, creating unsettling environments and atmospheres, or simply scary the daylights out of you, this game, despite its appearance, is not for the faint of heart

Metacritic Score: 64 Scariest Enemies: Killers, Monsters, Clowns Why Dead by Daylight is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Horror multiplayer games are almost always a mixed bag, as the sense of dread and terror that comes from this genre typically comes from isolation and psycholigcal torment, and its hard to take things all that seriously when playing with a bunch of wisecracking friends who react so over-the-top, it just becomes funny. Yet, somehow Dead by Daylight manages to toe the line of terror and comedy effortlessly, creating a multiplayer experience that is indeed fun, but can more than deliver on the frights.

Metacritic Score: 76 Scariest Enemies: Zombies, Humans Why Dying Light 2 Stay Human is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: The first Dying Light was a surprise hit that took the gaming world by storm thanks to its pretty impressive parkour mechanics and abundance of genuinely terrifying zombies. Dying Light 2: Staying Human, while not re-inventing the wheel in any way, continues to elevate and polish this zombie nightmare to terrifying perfection. With more focus on making sure the parkour mechanics feel smooth and dynamic, and the day-night cycle feeling as scary and present as ever, the game manages to bring more of a sense of dread to the franchise, while still keeping the overall game fun and frantic to play.

Release Date: 2024 Metacritic Score: 75 Scariest Enemies: Hard to explain, play it and you'll see.

Metacritic Score: 66 Scariest Enemies: Killer Clowns Why Killer Klowns from Outer Space: The Game is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: Killer Klowns from Outer Space: The Game transforms the cult classic horror-comedy film into a unique multiplayer asymmetrical horror experience, and while that has been done to death at this point, there is something quite special with this one. The game pits players in the role of either the outrageous alien Klowns or the human survivors trying to escape their wacky, yet deadly antics, and the vibrant and bizarre aesthetic is faithfully recreated with modern graphics. While its gameplay mechanics don't revolutionize the subgenre, it offers a fresh and entertaining twist that, for fans of the film especially, will deliver a fun and frightful experience.

Metacritic Score: 72 Scariest Enemies: Abominations, Crawlers, Mannequins Why Tormented Souls is one of the Best PS5 Horror Games: A love letter to the classic survival horror games of the 90s, Tormented Souls offers a meticulously crafted experience filled with puzzles, eerie environments, and chilling enemies. The fixed-camera perspectives, combined with a spooky story set in a desolate mansion, create an atmosphere dripping with tension and nostalgia, that, for fans of old-school horror gameplay, will delivers a richly rewarding and spine-tingling adventure.