Skip to content
maxnews
Games

Every Official NHL Game in the Franchise, Ranked

With the release of NHL 25 on October 4, 2024, it's time to update this ranking of every single NHL game and compare the newest entry to its predecessors. NHL 25 unfortunately isn't getting much love from critics or fans, as it currently has a Metacritic score of 66. Has EA made the series too formulaic? The cool thing about this list is your votes will determine the order, so all of those reviews and Internet comments go out the window in lieu of the crowd's opinion. Each NHL game is broken down here, highlighting their extraordinary features, exhilarating gameplay, and innovative design. From the glory days of EA Sports' vintage releases to the latest installments sparking a revolution on PlayStation, Xbox, and PC platforms, we cover every stride NHL has made over the years in the gaming space. Whether you are an old-time fan reveling in the nostalgia of NHL '94 or a newfound gaming aficionado intrigued by the recent release of NHL 25, the franchise truly has something for every kind of hockey fan. Vote up the NHL games you feel are the best in the franchise, no matter what year they were released.

Entries
36
Votes
17.5K
Updated
2 days ago

Tap upor downto vote. Your vote is added to Ranker's counts.

Voting identifies your browser with an anonymous fingerprint, stored only as a salted hash, to count one per visitor. Privacy

Source: Ranker, ranked by its voters.

  1. 1

    NHL 14

    Featuring the revolutionary Enforcer Engine, NHL 14 brought some much-needed changes to the series, combining the best of Fight Night and NHL gameplay into a seamless experience. The innovative collision physics system introduced in this iteration took into account speed, weight, direction, and more for realistic collisions on the ice. Skill Stick controls allow players to feel the smoothness of their dekes and shots, while the improved AI recognizes purposeful plays, making for an authentic hockey experience. NHL 14 had more than just gameplay improvements, as its presentation also underwent a significant overhaul, featuring a slick new menu system and enhanced commentary from legendary announcers Bill Clement and Gary Thorne.

    73% upvoted
  2. 2

    NHL '94

    Often heralded as one of the greatest sports video games of all time, NHL '94 was a true game-changer for the genre. The introduction of the one-timer shot forever changed hockey gaming and became a staple feature of the series moving forward. Additionally, NHL '94 touted a unique feature allowing players to control both their skater and goalie simultaneously, providing a whole new level of strategy during gameplay. Also noteworthy were the detailed player stats, team rankings, and season modes which laid the foundation for major features in future iterations of the NHL series.

    68% upvoted
  3. 3

    NHL 2004

    NHL 2004 revolutionized the series with its new Dynasty Mode, allowing players to make management decisions such as handling finances and building a championship team. The game also made significant improvements to the player animations, resulting in a more lifelike experience on the ice. The visuals of NHL 2004 were a notable step up from previous iterations, and the game excelled in creating a realistic atmosphere with authentic arenas, team logos, and player jerseys. NHL 2004's depth of gameplay, combined with its outstanding presentation, provided one of the most satisfying and realistic hockey gaming experiences of its era.

    63% upvoted
  4. 4

    NHL 07

    The introduction of the Skill Stick system in NHL 07 revolutionized the way players interacted with the game, giving them unprecedented control over the puck and their skater's movements. This innovative control mechanism set the stage for the later entries in the series and was widely praised for its intuitiveness and responsiveness. The game also featured a revamped Dynasty Mode, giving players more control over the management of their teams and setting the foundation for future iterations. Excellent graphics, realistic arenas, and smooth gameplay made NHL 07 a standout addition to the series, fine-tuning its mechanics and offering new levels of immersion.

    64% upvoted
  5. 5

    NHL 12

    NHL 12's revamped physics engine gave this entry in the series a far more realistic and gritty tone than its predecessors. Body checks sent players flying – or crashing – into the boards and a dynamic puck control system allowed for smoother, more precise movements on the ice. NHL 12 utilized a "Be a Pro" mode, which put players in the skates of a young hockey prospect with the potential to become a superstar, whether by breaking league records or earning prestigious awards. Furthermore, the game featured the Winter Classic, giving fans the chance to experience the excitement of outdoor hockey in a video game for the first time.

    60% upvoted
  6. 6

    NHL 10

    With NHL 10, Electronic Arts took the series to new heights by incorporating several fan-requested features into the gameplay. Most notably, the introduction of Battle for the Cup, a new playoff mode that gave players the opportunity to rewrite history by winning multiple championships with their favorite teams. The game also implemented the Intimidation Tactics feature, which enabled players to taunt opponents and energize their own teammates during games. These additions, coupled with improved graphics and physics, ensured an engaging, authentic hockey experience that resonated with fans of the sport.

    61% upvoted
  7. 7

    NHL 13

    Undoubtedly a turning point in the series, NHL 13 introduced the groundbreaking True Performance Skating system, which allowed for more responsive and fluid skater control. With over 1,000 new animations, this game offered an unmatched level of realism in movement, momentum, and explosiveness. In addition to these advancements, NHL 13 presented GM Connected mode, allowing players to create an online dynasty with friends by taking control of entire organizations. Lastly, the game broke barriers with the inclusion of female athletes for the first time, boasting the ability to play as renowned Olympians Hayley Wickenheiser and Angela Ruggiero.

    59% upvoted
  8. 8

    NHL 11

    NHL 11 raised the bar for hockey games with its innovative real-time physics engine, resulting in dynamic player interactions and more accurate in-game collisions. The increased authenticity extended beyond just physics, as NHL 11 incorporated several features, such as broken sticks and updated face-off mechanics, to ensure an immersive experience. The game's introduction of Hockey Ultimate Team, an all-new mode that combined card-collecting with team-building, allowed players to build their dream roster by collecting and trading virtual cards. With its impressive balance of depth in gameplay and new features, NHL 11 remains a standout entry in the series.

    60% upvoted
  9. 9

    NHL 09

    Heralded as a major step forward for the series, NHL 09 earned critical acclaim for its revamped control scheme, specifically the Skill Stick system, which provided players with a high level of accuracy and precision during in-game action. Furthermore, the game's Be a Pro mode put players in the shoes of a single NHL prospect, tasked with rising through the ranks to become a bona fide superstar. A comprehensive and innovative online mode, EA Sports Hockey League, introduced an entirely new level of multiplayer competition. NHL 09's seamless integration of new and improved gameplay features made it a fan favorite for years to come.

    59% upvoted
  10. 10

    NHL Legacy Edition

    Released to celebrate the franchise's storied history, NHL Legacy Edition seamlessly blended the best features from past games to deliver a thrilling hockey experience. The game provided a comprehensive experience for hockey aficionados, featuring updated rosters and improved AI for enhanced on-ice strategy and gameplay. The remarkable breadth of game modes, such as Be a GM, Be a Pro, Season Mode, and Online Versus, satisfied gamers' appetite for diverse and engaging hockey action. With its polished graphics, impressive soundtrack, and intuitive controls, NHL Legacy Edition solidified its status as a fitting tribute to the iconic series.

    61% upvoted